If therapy went badly before, name what went wrong, turn it into what you want instead, and ask about it before you start with someone new. At Foundations Counseling, with offices in Fort Collins, Loveland, and Windsor and online sessions in Colorado, we match you with a counselor first, and your first meeting with that counselor is a free consultation.
Key takeaways
- A bad experience is useful information. What went wrong last time tells you exactly what to look for this time.
- The most useful question comes straight from the National Institute of Mental Health: "What experience do you have treating someone with my issue?"
- Fit matters. NIMH puts it plainly: "Rapport and trust are essential."
- Ask practical questions when you reach out, and save the fit questions for your first meeting with the counselor.
- In Colorado, you can always get a second opinion or end therapy. One poor fit does not mean therapy will not work for you.
I had a bad therapy experience years ago, so how do I find someone different this time?
A bad experience is a real reason to be careful, not a reason to give up. What went wrong last time is the most useful thing you bring to the search. Here is a way to use it.
- Name what went wrong. Write one line for each thing: "I felt judged." "We talked but never set goals." "They did most of the talking."
- Turn each line into what you want instead. "I want someone who asks before assuming." "I want goals and regular check ins." "I want room to talk."
- Say it early. Mention it when you reach out, so it shapes who you are matched with, and raise it again in your first meeting with the counselor. A good therapist responds with curiosity, does not criticize the last therapist, and tells you how they would handle it differently.
- Decide how you will judge the first two sessions. Ask yourself: Did I feel heard? Did I understand the plan? Could I say something hard next time?
- Remember you can leave. Colorado law requires licensed therapists to give you written information "during the initial client contact," including this line: "The client may seek a second opinion from another therapist or may terminate therapy at any time."
If a past therapist crossed a serious boundary, you can report it. Colorado law states that "sexual intimacy is never appropriate and should be reported to the board" that licenses the therapist, through the Colorado Division of Professions and Occupations.
It also helps to know that fit is not a soft extra. A 2018 meta analysis by Fluckiger and colleagues of 295 studies with more than 30,000 patients found a consistent positive relation between the working bond with your therapist and how well therapy goes. A different fit can lead to a different experience.
What questions should I ask before I start with a new therapist?
Split your questions in two. Practical questions belong at the moment you reach out to a practice. Fit questions belong in your first real conversation with the counselor, because that is where you can hear how they think. Print this list and check off what you heard.
Your questions before you start (print this)
When you reach out to a practice
- What do you charge, how long is a session, and how does payment work?
- How soon could I be seen, and what times do you offer?
- Do you offer in person sessions, online sessions, or both?
- How do you decide which counselor I see, and what happens if the fit is wrong?
In your first meeting with the counselor
- What experience do you have treating someone with my issue?
- How do you usually work with a concern like mine, and what would the first few sessions look like?
- What license do you hold?
- How will we know it is working, and what happens if I feel I am not improving?
- What are the limits of confidentiality?
- What should I do if things get very hard between sessions?
If you had a bad experience before, add one more: "Last time, therapy did not work for me because ____. How would you handle that?"
Several of these come from public guidance. NIMH suggests asking about experience with your issue, how the provider usually treats it, how long treatment may last, and cost. Its psychotherapy guide adds a question many people skip: "What happens if you (or the therapist) feel you aren't starting to improve?" The American Psychological Association's guide to finding a good therapist suggests you "ask whether the therapist has had experience in dealing with your concerns."
What does a good answer sound like?
Experience and fit
Listen for specifics. A good answer names the kind of work they do with people like you and sounds like experience rather than willingness. "I work with everything" tells you little. Ask them to describe the first few sessions; you are listening for a plan, such as getting to know you, setting goals together, then a steady rhythm of sessions.
License
Colorado licenses talk therapists as LPC, LCSW, LMFT, and psychologist, and also issues candidate credentials (such as LPCC and SWC) to trained graduates who practice under supervision while they finish their hours. You can confirm any license yourself on the Colorado Division of Professions and Occupations license lookup. Our guide on how to find the best counselor for you explains each credential.
Progress
A strong therapist is comfortable with "How will we know it is working?" and with "What if it is not?" They might describe checking in on your goals every few weeks, or simply agreeing to talk about the therapy itself. Watch for defensiveness. Someone who welcomes the question is likely to welcome feedback later. As the APA guide to choosing a psychologist puts it, "A good rapport with your psychologist is critical."
Practical details
Clear numbers, given without hesitation, are a good sign. Ask about the fee, the session length, payment, and the cancellation window. If you plan to use insurance, ask whether the practice is in network or provides documentation for out of network reimbursement. Our comparison of private pay and insurance for therapy walks through the trade offs.
Privacy and safety
Every therapist should be able to explain, in plain words, what stays private and the few legal exceptions. They should also tell you what to do if you are in crisis between sessions, because most private practices are not emergency services.
What should I ask a therapist on the first phone call to figure out if they're a good fit?
It depends on how the practice works. Some therapists take a short call themselves before booking; if so, start with the practical questions and one or two fit questions from the list, such as their experience with your concern and what the first sessions would look like.
At Foundations, the first call is different. When you call 970.227.2770 or book online, you talk with our team, not a therapist. The team asks what brings you in, what you want to change, and practical details like office, schedule, and whether you prefer in person or online. That is the time for the "when you reach out" questions, and to mention anything that went wrong in past therapy. We use it to match you with a counselor whose training fits your concern. The fit questions belong in your free consultation with that counselor, because that is the person you are deciding about.
Which kind of option fits you?
Each kind of option has real strengths.
- Online directories give you the widest choice. You do the screening yourself, so the question list does most of the work.
- Apps and subscription platforms are built for convenience. Ask whether your therapist is licensed in Colorado and whether you keep the same person week to week.
- Large group practices often have more openings and can help you choose. Ask who you will actually see.
- Smaller local practices offer continuity and in person offices. Ask how they match clients and what happens if the first match is wrong.
Sometimes a different kind of care fits better. If you think medication may be part of your care, start with your physician or a psychiatrist, since prescribing belongs with them. If you are in crisis, do not wait for a callback: call or text 988, the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, or call 911 if you are in immediate danger.
How does starting at Foundations work?
Here is how it works, in order:
- Reach out. Call 970.227.2770 or book online, and share what you are looking for help with, including anything that did not work in past therapy.
- Get matched. Our team matches you with a counselor whose training fits your concern.
- Free consultation. Your first meeting with that matched counselor is a free consultation. Bring your question list; it is the right time to ask the fit questions. Same-day appointments are often available, and most new clients are seen within 48 hours of reaching out.
- Begin sessions, or switch. If the fit is not right, our Counselor Match Guarantee gives you the chance to meet with as many of our counselors as you need until you find the right one.
Sessions are private pay at $200 and usually last 50 minutes. Foundations is not in network with insurance carriers and provides documentation you can submit for out of network reimbursement. There is no charge for a session cancelled at least 48 hours ahead. We offer early morning, daytime, evening, and Saturday appointments at four offices: 400 East Horsetooth Road and 2809 East Harmony Road in Fort Collins, 5250 Hahns Peak Drive in Loveland, and 8201 Spinnaker Bay Drive in Windsor, plus online counseling for clients in Colorado. Learn more about individual counseling at Foundations.
Not sure therapy is for you yet? Read 5 reasons why people resist going to therapy. Helping someone else take this step? See 4 ways to talk to someone about going to therapy. Already started? Here is what to do between therapy sessions. More guides live in our therapy approaches library.
Frequently asked questions
I had a bad therapy experience years ago, so how do I find someone different this time?
Write down what went wrong and what you want instead, then say it when you reach out and again in your first meeting with the new counselor, and ask how they would handle it. Judge the first two sessions on whether you felt heard and understood the plan. In Colorado you can seek a second opinion or end therapy at any time.
What should I ask a therapist on the first phone call to figure out if they're a good fit?
Ask about their experience with your concern, how they would work with you, how you will both know therapy is working, what happens if the fit is wrong, and the practical details: fee, session length, availability, and in person or online options. At Foundations, the first call is with our team, and the fit questions belong in your free consultation with your matched counselor.
How do I know a new therapist is a better fit?
After the first session or two, ask yourself whether you felt heard without being rushed or judged, whether you understood their plan, and whether you could say something hard next time. If the answers are mostly no, it is fine to try someone else.
What happens when I call Foundations Counseling?
You share what you need with our team, and we match you with a counselor whose training fits your concern. Your first meeting with that matched counselor is a free consultation, where you can ask the fit questions on this list. Same-day appointments are often available, and most new clients are seen within 48 hours of reaching out.
Can I switch counselors at Foundations if the fit is wrong?
Yes. Under the Counselor Match Guarantee, you can meet with as many Foundations counselors as you need until you find the right one. Tell us what did not fit, and we will use that to make the next match.
Is the first consultation at Foundations free?
Yes. The first consultation is always free. After that, sessions are private pay at $200. Foundations is not in network with insurance carriers and provides documentation you can submit for out of network reimbursement.
Clinically reviewed by Chris Berger, M.A., LPC, NCC. Updated November 2026.
Sources: NIMH, Help for Mental Illnesses; NIMH, Psychotherapies; American Psychological Association, How Do I Find a Good Therapist?; American Psychological Association, How to choose a psychologist; Colorado Revised Statutes 12-245-216, Disclosure; Colorado Division of Professions and Occupations, license lookup; Fluckiger, Del Re, Wampold and Horvath, The Alliance in Adult Psychotherapy, Psychotherapy (2018).
Ready to talk with someone?
We will match you with a counselor who fits, and your first meeting with that counselor is a free consultation. Schedule your free consultation or call 970.227.2770.
If you are thinking about suicide or self harm, call or text 988, the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline. If you are in immediate danger, call 911.